16 Atlantic Avenue
Town
$2,450,000
Sale Pending
Days on Market: 154
Bed: 4 Bath: 4
Welcome to 16 Atlantic Avenue, ideally sited moments from Nantucket’s cobblestoned historic district, schools, the Windmill, and Mid-Island conveniences. This versatile property features two mirror-image, separately metered residences, each with two bedrooms, a full kitchen, designated outdoor spaces, and off-street parking. Whether you’re an investor seeking steady rental income, a homeowner interested in living on one side and renting the other, or looking to expand with the remaining ground coverage available, this rare offering presents a multitude of possibilities. Its prime location and flexible layout make it an appealing opportunity for a wide range of buyers.
Great Point Properties
4 Sunset Hill Lane
Town
$5,950,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 165
Bed: 5 Bath: 5
Four sunset hill is a home that breathes history tucked into the heart of Nantucket town and perched on a high point. This home tells the story of a full scale renovation where heritage meet soft, sculptural finishes, and history holds hands with modern ease. Restored with a fabulous floor plan incorporating an open living concept, 5 bedrooms, 5 ensuite baths, and several living areas to enjoy mornings lit by salt air and afternooons that harness the western sunset skies. Not to be missed; the 7 window sun porch, cozy and private den with gas fireplace, custom built-ins throughout infusing every space with warmth and intention. High level elements include gorgeous marble tile baths and stunning custom cabinetry. Offered turn-key and fully furnished this property ultimately provides for quiet luxury, tailored textures, and the effortless comfort of knowing everything is exactly where it should be. Not to mention that you can pop out your front door and only a short jaunt away you will find the best shopping, Nantucket’s finest resaurants, and premier beaches. Property slated for completion Aug, 2025.
Maury People Sotheby’s International Realty
27 Fair Street
Town
$5,995,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 125
Bed: 15 Bath: 15
Sitting high on Fair Street on a oversized rolling lot, 27 Fair Street was originally built as a single family home and then later converted to an inn with an annex building at the rear of the lot. There are plans to reconfigure the existing inn into a six key inn and build three, free-standing two-story suites where the annex building currently exists. Or, convert back to a single family home with plenty of room for a guest house as the expansive lot has over 178′ of frontage on Hillers Lane.
J Pepper Frazier Co.
29 Fair Street
Town
$2,950,000
Active Under Contract
Days on Market: 125
Bed: 9 Bath: 9
Originally built in 1709 for the George Bunker family. The property was converted to the Woodbox Inn in 1931. Located at the top of the hill, on one of Nantucket’s most charming streets, 29 Fair Street is a rare opportunity to restore a piece of Nantucket’s architectural heritage that’s steeped in history. Many original features are still intact. Potential for sub-division.
J Pepper Frazier Co.
10 Center Street
Sconset
$2,595,000
Price Change
Days on Market: 122
Bed: 4 Bath: 4
Nestled in the heart of Sconset Village with origins in the early 1700s, this exquisitely renovated antique ‘Whale Cottage’ blends timeless character with modern luxury. Offering 4 bedrooms, a brand-new kitchen & bathroom, and all new landscaping, this single-family home has been impeccably updated by Gull and Goose Antiques with top-quality materials and curated with a thoughtful selection of period antiques, creating a warm, elegant, and timeless retreat. Set on one of the most picturesque and iconic lanes in Sconset, where rambling roses climb the historic cottages and summer breezes float in from the sea, “Don’t Give Up the Ship” offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of Nantucket history. Every inch of the home is both purposeful and beautiful, designed to honor the past while embracing modern living. This cottage captures the magic of ‘Sconset—frozen in time, yet refreshingly refined. Ready for immediate occupancy and being sold mostly furnished.
J Pepper Frazier Co.
3 Cottage Avenue
Sconset
$1,595,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 36
Bed: 1 Bath: 1
Discover a rare, thoughtfully reimagined jewel box in the heart of ’Sconset Village. Designer-led renovation with exceptional attention to detail, 3 Cottage Avenue offers the perfect turnkey pied-à-terre. Once part of the historic Moby Dick Hotel, these few privately owned cottages rarely change hands. Enjoy ocean views from a private yard framed by mature gardens, window boxes, and roses at this timeless escape. “Yes” is truly a must-see.
Lee Real Estate
65B Surfside Road
Mid Island
$849,000
Active Under Contract
Days on Market: 65
Bed: Bath:
Opportunities abound on this vacant lot located in an established area of Surfside. R-5 zoned with 2,000 square feet of allowable ground cover to build your dream home or investment property. Property is conveniently situated near mid-island shopping, Town and Surfside Beaches. Utilities (water, sewer and conduits for electric) have all been brought to and stubbed at the property.
William Raveis Nantucket
4 McKinley Avenue
Sconset
$3,775,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 144
Bed: 2 Bath: 2
Fantastic location in ‘Sconset Village on a generously oversized lot just off Main Street, featuring ample lawn area framed by stunning mature trees. “La Serre” is a single-story two-bedroom home, built in the early 1900s and once part of a grand Main Street estate with a story-book quality that embraces the classic Sconset charm. The living room has generous space and opens onto a conservatory that offers a three-season living space. The property is serviced by Town water and Town sewer and offers multiple options for the next owner. The opportunity to own an oversized property in a desirable village location does not happen often.
Great Point Properties
42 Main Street
Sconset
$9,750,000
Price Change
Days on Market: 104
Bed: 6 Bath: 6
Aptly named ‘Time Out’, this private Sconset Estate with an exquisite five bedroom main house, one bedroom guest house, heated pool and over sized garage is a summer oasis! The property is completely hedged in, abuts acres and acres of Nantucket Conservation Foundation open space and is set back from the street, with mature plantings and a lovely front and rear yard, affording much privacy. Designed by Botticelli and Pohl architects, this is an ideal home for multi generational use with five bedroom suites, three floors of finished living space, custom paneling throughout the home as wall as many built in details. There is a wonderful and bright ‘Chef’s Kitchen’ with all top of the line appliances and ample storage. The south facing patio and deck flows easily to the back yard and pool for summer enjoyment and entertaining. This is a wonderful opportunity to own on Sconset Main Street with close proximity to the center of town, beaches, Nantucket Golf Club, Sankaty Golf Club and the Sconset Casino. This stunning home with its timeless architecture is perfectly maintained and is ready to be enjoyed for many more years to come!
Lee Real Estate
32 Union Street
Town
$6,595,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 71
Bed: 5 Bath: 5
Beautifully restored and maintained home in the heart of the Old Historic District, with Main St and the waterfront at your doorstep. Built is 1786, the William Coffin House offers 5 bedrooms and multiple indoor and outdoor living spaces over three floors. Historic details blend seamlessly with modern convenience and comfort. Ample roof walk offers stunning harbor views. Private back yard and multiple off-street park spaces.
William Raveis Nantucket
4 Cathcart Road
Monomoy
$11,750,000
Price Change
Days on Market: 58
Bed: Bath:
Tucked away in one of the island’s most peaceful enclaves, this expansive parcel at 4 Cathcart Road presents a rare chance to craft a private compound unlike any other. With generous acreage (7+ acres), the land has potential to accommodate a main residence, guest cottage, and a full suite of lifestyle amenities — from a swimming pool to a tennis court — all set within a serene natural landscape.
Just 700′ away from shoreline access, the property enjoys the potential for elevated vistas of the harbor and striking evening skies from a future second floor. Its unique contours provide a dynamic canvas for visionary site planning, while the bordering Nantucket Conservation Foundation land ensures enduring privacy and a connection to untouched surroundings.
An approved Notice of Intent (NOI) is already in place, and a viewing platform on-site offers a glimpse of the extraordinary setting.
Maury People Sotheby’s International Realty
24 Macys Lane
Mid Island
$3,275,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 144
Bed: 6 Bath: 6
Welcome to this exceptional custom-built residence offering 3,778 sq ft under air plus a massive basement with soaring 10-foot ceilings—a rare find with endless potential for expansion or customization.This meticulously crafted home showcases premium finishes throughout, including rich walnut floors, a brand-new A/C system, and a spacious second-level deck perfect for outdoor living. The oversized garage adds both convenience and ample storage. The property is currently configured as two separate living units: First Floor Unit (Updated in 2021): 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, full kitchen, and beautifully designed living spaces.
Second Floor Unit: 3 bedrooms, 3 full baths—ideal for extended family, guests, or generating rental income.
Whether you’re looking to live in one unit and rent the other, or explore the unfinished basement’s potential as additional living space, a home office, gym, or entertainment suite—this home offers unmatched versatility and value.
BHHS Island Properties Nantucket
20 Evergreen Way
Surfside
$3,095,000
Price Change
Days on Market: 112
Bed: 4 Bath: 4
The approach to this lovely property is down a hedge-lined driveway, leading to a peaceful and beautifully manicured setting that features a three-bedroom main house and a one-bedroom cottage. The main house was recently expanded and features a first-floor bedroom, as well as generously sized rooms with a design that opens to the outdoors. In addition, thoughtful custom details are featured throughout, including a custom kitchen, a handsome wood-paneled den, and three fireplaces. The one-bedroom cottage is light-filled and offers additional living space for a home office and/or overflow. The property is nearly one acre and benefits from Town water and Town sewer, which will support expansion and additional structures like a garage or pool.
Great Point Properties
17 Cannonbury Lane
Sconset
$6,995,000
Active Under Contract
Days on Market: 17
Bed: 7 Bath: 7
Living The Nantucket summer lifestyle, from the proximity to Pebble beach and ’Sconset Village to the perfect blend of classic coastal design with modern amenities. The compound consists of six-bedroom main house with three finished levels, plus a guest suite and poolside cabana, offers both luxury and versatility. There is great seamless indoor-outdoor living, especially with the outdoor features like the large pool, bluestone patio, built-in grill and gas fire pit. Included in this new construction compound is deeded beach access and exclusive use of the clubhouse, gym, and cutting garden.
J Pepper Frazier Co.
158 Madaket Road
Madaket
$2,395,000
Price Change
Days on Market: 137
Bed: Bath:
A rare and exceptional opportunity to own a prime 2-acre building lot on Nantucket Island. This expansive parcel is high, dry, and free of wetlands—an ideal blank canvas for your dream compound. Surrounded by acres of pristine conservation land, the setting offers unmatched privacy, tranquility, and natural beauty. Viewing stand in place and you cannot even see your abutting neighbors.
With approximately 3,470 square feet of available ground cover, the lot provides ample space for a main residence, guest house, garage, pool, and even a tennis court if desired. Town water is accessible at the street, and an approved 8-bedroom septic design will convey with the sale.
Create a legacy property tailored to your vision in one of the island’s most serene and protected environments. A unique opportunity to build your Nantucket dream estate.
BHHS Island Properties Nantucket
Contact us for more information.