21 North Pasture Lane
Polpis
$6,995,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 185
Bed: 4 Bath: 4
Spacious two-story residence with four bedrooms suites, situated in North Pasture abutting vast tracts of conservation land with easy access to miles of recreational trails through the central moors. The open-concept layout is filled with natural light, featuring a spacious great room with a large fireplace and vaulted ceilings seamlessly connected to a sunny kitchen and dining area with direct access to multiple patios—ideal for entertaining or relaxing. The luxurious first-floor primary suite offers a private retreat, while a first-floor guest suite with an en-suite bath provides comfortable guest accommodations. Additional main-level highlights include a sunny office or den, a stylish powder room, and a versatile laundry room that doubles as a pantry and beach gear storage. Upstairs, two generously sized guest suites each offer a private balcony and full bath. A flexible bonus space completes the upper level—perfect for a nursery, playroom, or second office. Includes a garage with storage area. Outdoor living is enhanced by multiple patios, including an outdoor shower. Rendering shows a conceptual design of a swimming pool prepared by Champoux Landscape. Upscale neighborhood has easy access to miles of scenic trails through conservation land, the nearby bike path, and Moors End Farm, this home offers the perfect balance of privacy, recreation, and convenience. This is a truly rare offering—where elevated design, location, and lifestyle converge in one of Nantucket’s most desirable settings.
Maury People Sotheby’s International Realty
14 Flintlock Road
Tom Nevers
$2,549,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 260
Bed: 4 Bath: 4
Set on one of the most picturesque lots in Tom Nevers East, this newly renovated 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy and natural beauty. Surrounded by a tree-covered lawn and backing up to 28 acres of protected Land Bank property, the 1.1-acre parcel provides space to unwind and room to breathe. Yes, there IS room for a pool!! Inside, you’ll find gleaming hardwood floors, new Anderson 400 Series windows and a fresh, modern feel throughout. The spacious mahogany deck and outdoor shower invite you to soak in the Nantucket lifestyle, whether you’re entertaining guests or enjoying a quiet moment outdoors. This home has never been used as a vacation rental, giving you the rare opportunity to be the first to create lasting memories in a space that feels brand new. Residents of Tom Nevers East enjoy access to community tennis courts and are just minutes from the stunning beaches along the South Shore. Whether you’re looking for a peaceful year-round retreat or a summer escape, this property delivers laid-back island living at its best.
William Raveis Nantucket
4 Sunset Hill Lane
Town
$5,495,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 61
Bed: 5 Bath: 5
Nestled on an elevated site at the edge of Town, Four Sunset Hill has been thoughtfully reimagined through a full-scale renovation, blending history and modern sophistication in perfect harmony. The home features an exceptional floor plan with five spacious bedrooms, each with its own ensuite bath, and multiple inviting living areas. Highlights include an enclosed and western-facing sun porch, a cozy private den with a gas fireplace, and thoughtful details that lend warmth, character, and purpose to every corner. Marble countertops and custom cabinetry elevate the home’s refined aesthetic. Offered turn-key and fully furnished, Four Sunset Hill offers curated design and the ease of knowing every detail has been considered. Nantucket’s iconic island landmarks, shops and restaurants are just moments away from the front door.
Fisher Real Estate
33.5 Vesper Lane
South of Town
$5,995,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 143
Bed: 6 Bath: 6
Welcome to 33 1/2 Vesper – Your Coastal Retreat! NOW approved for a pool! Plans included.
Nestled in the heart of Nantucket Island, this charming property offers a perfect blend of modern luxury and traditional island charm. With its prime location, just moments away from pristine beaches and picturesque cobblestone streets, 33 1/2 Vesper promises an unforgettable getaway. With a total of six bedrooms spread out across a three level main house and cottage, this is a home designed to provide comfort, tranquility, and an inviting ambiance. Enjoy an open-concept layout with abundant natural light, perfect for entertaining or relaxing with family and friends. Fully equipped with stainless steel appliances, marble countertops, and custom cabinetry, inspiring culinary creativity. Six beautifully appointed bedrooms, designed for comfort, ensuring restful nights. A beautifully landscaped yard features 2 spacious outdoor dining areas, ideal for alfresco meals or sunbathing. Situated near shops, restaurants, and local attractions, this home offers the best of Nantucket living. This property is move-in ready, allowing you to enjoy the island lifestyle immediately. 33.5 Vesper Lane is your Nantucket story waiting to be written.
Shepherd Real Estate
256 Polpis Road
Polpis
$33,000,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 199
Bed: 12 Bath: 12
256 Polpis Road is an exceptional 6.42-acre legacy estate that offers stunning views and direct water access to Polpis Harbor. Botticelli and Pohl Architects, and Hehir Group Custom Builders have spent two years thoughtfully and completely reimagining this grand and refined historic home. This rare offering is ready for immediate enjoyment for those seeking luxury living and the best that Nantucket has to offer. 256 Polpis Road boasts over 15,000 square feet of living space with sweeping vistas and panoramic views of the water, surrounded by lush natural landscape guided by Ahearn Landscape Design. At the heart of the property stands a spectacular main house boasting 10 bedroom suites, 3 floors of finished living space, floor-to-ceiling windows throughout highlighting the exceptional scenery, an 18X48′ infinity-edge swimming pool, cabana, two-car garage, gym, movie theatre, and a billiard room.
Winding trails lead directly to the harbor, offering access to cherished Nantucket pastimes like kayaking, clamming, and waterfront exploration. At the heart of this exceptional estate is a historically significant, iconic boathouse—a rare and irreplaceable amenity that’s every skipper’s dream. The property also presents the potential to secure an estate-side mooring, further elevating its appeal.
Meticulously designed and curated by SLC Interiors, the residence is offered fully furnished, with no detail overlooked. Additionally, buyers have the opportunity to bring their vision to life with a custom two-bedroom carriage house. This is more than a home—it’s a Nantucket experience not to be missed.
Great Point Properties
16H Milestone Road
Monomoy
$1,675,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 176
Bed: 2 Bath: 2
Nestled in the center of Nantucket, this free-standing 2-bedroom, 2-bath cottage condo offers the perfect blend of coastal charm and modern convenience. With 928 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space including a spacious loft ideal for overflow or a cozy home office this property lives larger than expected. The updated kitchen and bathrooms feature contemporary finishes, while cathedral ceilings and a wood burning fireplace add warmth and character. Step outside to a private backyard complete with an outdoor shower – perfect after a day at the beach. Enjoy year round comfort with central air conditioning and take advantage of rental potential in this centrally located gem. Whether you’re looking for a personal island escape or a smart investment this charming cottage delivers on all fronts.
William Raveis Nantucket
4 Cathcart Road
Monomoy
$11,750,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 122
Bed: Bath:
Tucked away in one of the island’s most peaceful enclaves, this expansive parcel at 4 Cathcart Road presents a rare chance to craft a private compound unlike any other. With generous acreage (7+ acres), the land has potential to accommodate a main residence, guest cottage, and a full suite of lifestyle amenities — from a swimming pool to a tennis court — all set within a serene natural landscape.
Just 700′ away from shoreline access, the property enjoys the potential for elevated vistas of the harbor and striking evening skies from a future second floor. Its unique contours provide a dynamic canvas for visionary site planning, while the bordering Nantucket Conservation Foundation land ensures enduring privacy and a connection to untouched surroundings.
An approved Notice of Intent (NOI) is already in place, and a viewing platform on-site offers a glimpse of the extraordinary setting.
Maury People Sotheby’s International Realty
3 & 3A Reeds Way
Tom Nevers
$8,995,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 115
Bed: 9 Bath: 9
Oceanfront Retreat | 3 & 3A Reeds Way
Positioned along Nantucket’s striking south shore, offering privately owned deeded beach access, this rare oceanfront offering includes two residences with panoramic Atlantic vistas and private shoreline access. Beginning in spring of 2025, the property has been thoughtfully upgraded with new cedar roofing, shingles, trim, and exterior lighting; modern boilers for heat and hot water; expanded decks; a six-foot eastern lawn extension with retaining walls; refreshed landscaping; and updated interior electrical systems. Approved plans from the HDC feature a generous 14’ x 34’ pool and a private staircase for direct beach access. Ready for immediate enjoyment, the estate provides the ideal balance of move-in comfort today with the flexibility to design your long-term vision. Experience the tranquility of Tom Nevers with this exceptional chance to own a waterfront compound featuring both a 5 bedroom Main House and 4 bedroom Guest cottage.
Maury People Sotheby’s International Realty
1 Reeds Way
Tom Nevers
$9,995,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 115
Bed: 6 Bath: 6
A once in a life time opportunity to own this extraordinary six-bedroom, five-bathroom residence on nearly three acres of premier oceanfront, rising 45 feet above sea level with expansive decks soaring to approximately 65 feet. The result: uninterrupted, panoramic views of the Atlantic—capturing the island’s most breathtaking sunrises and sunsets from dawn to dusk.
In 2025, the property underwent a comprehensive transformation, blending timeless Nantucket character with modern luxury. Upgrades include a new cedar roof and shingles, refreshed trim and exterior lighting, extended decking, high-efficiency heating and hot water systems, updated interior electrical, and beautifully reimagined landscaping with retaining walls and expanded lawns.
The resort-caliber outdoor amenities are designed for both relaxation and entertaining: a heated pool, hot tub, outdoor kitchen, twin outdoor showers, and a brand-new poolside cabana with full basement. Custom-designed easy sloping stairs provide direct access to the beach, creating seamless transitions from ocean swims to gatherings on elevated terraces.
Move-in ready today yet offering abundant potential for personalization, this is a rare opportunity to own one of Nantucket’s most elevated and inspiring oceanfront settings.
Maury People Sotheby’s International Realty
1,3,&3A Reeds Way
Tom Nevers
$18,990,000
Withdrawn
Days on Market: 115
Bed: 15 Bath: 15
1, 3 & 3A Reeds Way. Elevated Oceanfront Expanding Over Nearly 6 Acres.
A once in a lifetime opportunity to own this rare Tom Nevers offering brings together three ocean-facing residences across nearly six acres of premier frontage. Each home enjoys sweeping Atlantic views, direct beach access, and an elevated vantage point reaching up to ~65 feet above sea level.
The property has been thoughtfully updated in 2025 with all-new cedar roofs and shingles, trim, windows, sliding doors, efficient heating systems, electrical upgrades, and extended decking designed for seamless indoor–outdoor living.
The grounds showcase a resort-inspired setting: expansive lawns, a 18′ by 36′ heated pool, with auto cover two hot tubs, poolside cabana, outdoor kitchen, and dual outdoor showers—perfect for hosting gatherings across every season. Ample parking serves all three homes, while broad porches and ocean-facing decks frame the island’s most captivating sunrises and sunsets.
Situated on private Reeds Way—yours to rename and make your own—this compound offers the flexibility to create a unified estate, preserve multiple guest houses, or hold as a multi-generational retreat. With rare acreage, dramatic elevation, and unobstructed Atlantic vistas, the property is as much an investment in lifestyle as it is in land.
Maury People Sotheby’s International Realty
Contact us for more information.